Cunning Wish [Judge Gift Cards 2007] BW27 a butterfly flapping its wings

a butterfly flapping its wings is insufficient

The same is true for permanent spells you control and nonland permanent cards you own that aren't on the battlefield

and Rarity

Set: Diamond & Pearl: Secret Wonders Type: Colorless Rarity: Holo Rare Retreat cost: Colorless

Set: EX: Crystal Guardians Type: Fighting Rarity: Rare Retreat cost: Colorless

Cunning Wish [Judge Gift Cards 2007] BW27 a butterfly flapping its wingsSet: Judge Gift Cards 2007 Type: Instant Rarity: Rare Cost: {2}{U} You may reveal an instant card you own from outside the game and put it into your hand. Exile Cunning Wish. The foolish wish for that which they desire. The cunning wish for that which they require.